News

Bad reasoning

I am somewhat concerned by the comments made by Ben Black of Tinies nanny agency regarding Kelly Lawrence, the nanny imprisoned for abusing two 14-month-old toddlers in her care, as 'a decent nanny who went bad', and concerned that she was a qualified childcarer (News, 10 January). Being 'decent' is not an indicator. Its meaning is useless. Does this then mean that a doctor who has a hangover and kills a patient just 'went bad'?
I am somewhat concerned by the comments made by Ben Black of Tinies nanny agency regarding Kelly Lawrence, the nanny imprisoned for abusing two 14-month-old toddlers in her care, as 'a decent nanny who went bad', and concerned that she was a qualified childcarer (News, 10 January).

Being 'decent' is not an indicator. Its meaning is useless. Does this then mean that a doctor who has a hangover and kills a patient just 'went bad'?

The reality is that this qualified childcarer abused two small, vulnerable children in her care over a period of time and it was not an isolated incident that happened one afternoon in the park.

I owned a nanny agency in Northern Ireland for seven years and was fortunate to have access to a pre-employment check service by both the police and social services that enabled me to conduct a thorough check of a nanny to ensure she was employable in the care of children. That check, along with all our other very stringent checks, provided parents with a safety net.

It would seem from Mr Black's comments that nannies can be decent (which I am sure 99.9 per cent are) but if they have an off day, well, they just 'went bad'.

It is time the Government took proper action and set up a register for ALL childcarers in the UK. And who, I wonder, looks after baby Leo Blair while his parents go abroad?

Dorothy Greer, Belfast

Early Years Educator

Munich (Landkreis), Bayern (DE)

Deputy Manager

Play Out Nursery in Ipswich

Nursery Practitioner

Play Out Nursery in Ipswich